For An Annual Commitment Of Just $5 - Become An Individual Subscriber/Supporter Of WNYLaborToday.com
Subscriber Log In
New York Alliance for Retired Americans WNY Chapter of NYSARA
NEW YORK STATE ALLIANCE FOR RETIRED AMERICANS
Stephen Muscarella, President
NYS PEF Retirees
Email: sjmuskie@roadrunner.com

Info

With More Than 500,000 Retired Union Members Living Across New York State Today, Including More Than 100,000 Right Here in Western New York, WNYLaborToday.com is Proud to be Working With the Representatives of the Western New York Chapter of the New York State Alliance For Retired Americans (NYSARA) in Order to Provide Union Retirees With a Variety of Labor News and Information They Need and Just Won’t Find Anywhere Else.

The Western New York Chapter of the New York Alliance For Retired Americans Serves as the Base for Providing Union Retirees a Voice that Can Be Heard.

Stephen Muscarella is NYSARA’s President Here in Western New York and Also Serves as President of the New York State Public Employees Federation (PEF).

For More Information on the Western New York Chapter of the New York State Alliance For Retired Americans and How You Can Get Involved, Contact Stephen Muscarella Directly Via E-Mail at sjmuskie@roadrunner.com.

Recent News

More news >>

When America Was 'Great,' Taxes Were ‘High,’ Unions Were ‘Strong’ & Government Was ‘Big:’ The ‘Bygone Nation’ Donald Trump’s Supporters Yearn For Looks Awfully Liberal

Published Wednesday, September 30, 2015
by www.theatlantic.com

There’s plenty about GOP hopeful Donald Trump to which potential primary voters respond.

He’s successful.

He’s plainspoken.

At a time when politicians are historically unpopular, he’s not a politician.

And he has a great slogan.

That slogan resonates with his supporters, according to Republican Pollster Frank Luntz, who ran a recent focus group, the results of which were written about in Time.

“I used to sleep on my front porch with the door wide open, and now everyone has deadbolts,” one man told Luntz. “I believe the best days of the country are ‘behind us.’”

Luntz concluded people see Trump as a real-deal/fixer-upper, able to make repairs that others have bungled.

“We know his goal is to make America ‘great again,’” one woman astutely observed. “It’s on ‘his’ hat.”

It could be on your hat too - Trump has begun selling Make America Great Again merchandise -if you can find one, that is.

They have a tendency to sell out

As Russell Berman pointed out in The Atlantic earlier this month, many White Americans these days are pessimistic to the point of despair: White Americans - and in particular those under 30 or nearing retirement age - have all but given up on the American Dream.  More than four out of five younger Whites, and more than four out of five respondents between the ages of 51 and 64 said The Dream is suffering.

No wonder Trump’s message is so powerful - it’s a sugar pill coated with nostalgia.

He’s not promising to make America great, he’s promising to make it great - again.

But to what era does he intend to take the nation back?

And what would that look like, practically speaking?

The boundaries of America’s Golden Age are clear on one end and fuzzy on the other.

Everyone agrees that the mid-century boom times began after Allied soldiers returned in triumph from World War II.

But when did they wane?

The economist Joe Stiglitz, in an article in Politico Magazine titled: The Myth Of The American Golden Age, sets the endpoint at 1980, a year until which “the fortunes of the wealthy and the Middle Class ‘rose together.’” 

Others put the cut-off earlier at the economic collapse of 1971 and the ensuring malaise.

Regardless of when it ended, it would not be unfair to use the 50s as shorthand for this now glamorized period of plenty, peace and the kind of optimism only plenty and peace can produce.

In 1950, America led the world in GDP per capita.

Even by 1973, it had only sunk to number two.

Jobs were so plentiful that male employment peaked at over 84%.

Unemployment, when it did Strike, didn’t last long.

Housing was cheap.

Gas was cheap.

Movies were cheap.

If America was ever great, it was great in 1950, and one can sympathize with a desire to recreate those economic conditions, if not the social ones. 

Most of Trump’s supporters (but not all) deserve some benefit of the doubt that when they look wistfully at the past, they aren’t yearning for Jim Crow Laws, Communist witch hunts, or an age before women could own credit cards.

Still, Trump’s supporters might not appreciate what an economic return to the 50s - even a 50s lacking overt discrimination against women and political, racial, and sexual minorities - would entail.

The 50s were, as Stiglitz puts it, “a time of war-induced solidarity when the government kept the playing field level.”

In other words, they were a time of Big Government.

And Big Labor, as Alternet reports: “By 1953, more than one out of three American Workers were Members of Private Sector Unions.  That means there was a Union Member in nearly every family.”

Then there’s the matter of taxes.

Though a conservative writer at Bloomberg’s Viewscoffs at the oft-cited statistic that the top marginal tax rate in the 50s was an astounding 91%, even she admits that “the Internal Revenue Service reckoned that the effective rate of tax in 1954 for top earners was actually seventy-percent” - vastly higher than it is today.

Indeed, for most of the past 100 years, tax rates have been much higher than they are now, including during some boom times.  

If bigger government, stronger Unions and higher taxes on the rich are what it takes to make America great again, Republican primary voters might be surprised to learn that the candidate who truly shares their values is not Donald Trump - but Bernie Sanders.

You Can Directly Access This Labor News Story at: www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/09/when-america-was-great-taxes-were-high-unions-were-strong-and-government-was-big/407284/

 

 

Comments

Leave a Comment


WNYLaborToday.com provides the following links to a number of helpful and useful Union Plus Programs:
Consumer Reports Health and Best Buy Drugs:
UnionPlus.org/Health
Health Savings Programs:
Call 1-877-570-4945 or visit UnionPlus.org/HealthSavings
Hospital Care Grants:
UnionPlus.org/UnionSAFE
Medical Bill Negotiation Service:
UnionPlus.org/BillNegotiator
On-line Prescription Discount Card:
UnionPlus.org/RxCard
Wellness Programs:
UnionPlus.org/HealthClubs
Visit www.UnionPlus.org, which provides an array of information on a number of money-saving programs that can keep your family and finances in good health: